The Loyalists
The 40,000 United Empire Loyalists who streamed north to
British Canada in the aftermath of the American War of Independence
accounted for a sizeable chunk of the New England population. Many
had been subjected to reprisals by their revolutionary neighbours
and most arrived virtually penniless. All but 8000 settled in the
Maritime provinces, where they and their descendants formed the
kernel of powerful commercial and political cliques. As a result,
the Loyalists have frequently - and not altogether unfairly - been
pilloried as arch-conservatives, but in fact they were far from
docile subjects: indeed shortly after their arrival in Canada they
were pressing the British for their own elective assemblies.
Crucially, they were also to instil in their new country an abiding
dislike for the American version of republican democracy - and this
has remained a key sentiment threading through Canadian
history.
Before their enforced exile, the Loyalists conducted a fierce
debate with their more radical compatriots, but whereas almost
everyone today knows the names of the revolutionary leaders, the
Loyalists are forgotten. The Loyalist argument had several strands
- loyalty to Britain, fear of war, the righteousness of civil
obedience and, rather more subliminally, the traditional English
Tory belief that men are most free living in a hierarchical society
where roles are clearly understood. One of their most articulate
spokesmen was Daniel Leonard, who during his epistolatory debate
with John Adams wrote: "A very considerable part of the men of
property in this province, are at this day firmly attached to the
cause of government … [and will] … if they fight at all, fight
under the banners of loyalty … And now, in God's name, what is it
that has brought us to this brink of destruction? Has not the
government of Great Britain … been a nursing mother to us? Has she
not been indulgent almost to a fault?… Will not posterity be
amazed, when they are told that the present destruction took its
rise from a three penny duty on tea, and call it a more
unaccountable frenzy … than that of the witchcraft?"
Copyright Rough Guides Ltd as trustee for its authors. Published by Rough Guides. All rights reserved.
The Rough Guides name is a trademark of Rough Guides Ltd.